CrimeTalk

An educational resource for students and staff studying the sociology of crime, deviance and social censure, criminology, sociology of law and socio-legal studies;  the intriguing stuff that made the subject fascinating in the first place. So much of this has now become political that we also discuss politics.

Interesting data

UNODC's 2011 Global Study on Homicide

Star InactiveStar InactiveStar InactiveStar InactiveStar Inactive

The 2011 Global Study on Homicide has been conceived to provide a unique overview of the ultimate crime. The picture it paints is of a phenomenon marked by large disparities in distribution, demographics, typologies and mechanisms.

At one extreme, where homicide rates are high and firearms and organized crime in the form of drug trafficking play a substantial role, 1 in 50 men aged 20 will be murdered before they reach the age of 31. At the other, the probability of such an occurrence is up to 400 times lower.

There are many reasons for this but one of the links most clearly identified in this study is that homicide is much more common in countries with low levels of human development, high levels of income inequality and weak rule of law than in more equitable societies, where socio-economic stability seems to be something of an antidote to homicide.

Disparities not only exist in homicide typologies but also in their prevalence in different regions and countries, yet this study shows that intimate partner/family-related homicide is a chronic problem everywhere. Women murdered by their past or present male partner make up the vast majority of its victims worldwide, which explains why in many countries women are more likely to be murdered in the home than elsewhere.

Men, on the other hand, make up the vast majority of both victims and perpetrators of all types of crime, including homicide, and are more likely to be killed in the street. They are also more likely to be young, the street is more likely to be in a built up area and they are most likely to be killed with a gun.

It is the comprehensive cross-national and time series homicide data from 207 countries and territories, forming the backbone of the Global Study on Homicide, which has enabled the extensive multi-national team behind it to come to such concrete conclusions. Analysis of this nature is fundamental in understanding the forces that drive homicide so that measures and policies can be developed to help bring about its reduction.

Education reduces crime: 3-state recidivism study

Star InactiveStar InactiveStar InactiveStar InactiveStar Inactive

You have to wonder why studies like this one by Stephen Steurer and Linda Smith are not publicized more widely. Maybe its conclusions produce such positive findings about the impact of prison education on rehabilitation and recidivism that the imagined costs of providing good prison education systems frighten impecunious governmental funding agencies or politicians whose electoral prospects depend on holding to a 'lock em up and throw away the key' philosophy from the dark ages.

http://eric.ed.gov/PDFS/ED478452.pdf

Its main conclusion is that, using a sample of over 3,000 inmates, participants in prison education programmes in Minnesota, Ohio and Maryland had lower recidivism rates. This was true with both vocational and college/post-secondary educational programmes - both led to higher wages and more chance of 'going straight'. 

The research design involved many leading correctional studies experts and was felt to be the best ever on this subject in 2003, its year of publication. The research was fortunate in having unusually good access to state financial records concerning employment and tax.

If we want to improve public safety and reduce recodivism, and many experienced criminologists would agree with me that this is a big 'if', it is clear that rigidly and obsessively using incarceration is not the way to go, and looks like a sign of ignorance, expediency or desperation.

As the authors put it, research consistently shows that offenders are "capable of positive change". Not only that, government analysts in Maryland calculated that those non-returning inmates saved the taxpayer $24 million p.a.; double the cost of the prison education programmes - not to mention the additional tax revenue gained from the newly employed non-returnees.

Colin Sumner

 

High rates of mental health issues and risky health behaviours among Australia’s prisoners

Star InactiveStar InactiveStar InactiveStar InactiveStar Inactive

Australia’s prisoners have high levels of mental health issues and risky health behaviours, according to a report released today by the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW).

The health of Australia’s prisoners 2010 is the second AIHW report to examine prisoner health in Australia, using National Prisoner Health Indicators. It uses data from the National Prisoner Health Census, which was conducted over a two week period on all prison entrants, except those in New South Wales and Victoria (these jurisdictions will participate in the future).

The report shows that in 2010, over 30% of prison entrants said they had been told at some point in their lives before coming to prison that they had a mental health illness.

‘On entry to prison, almost one-fifth of new prisoners were referred to the prison’s mental health services for observation and further assessment,’ said AIHW spokesperson Tim Beard.

‘During the 2 week prisoner census period, almost 1 in 10 prisoners visited the clinic for a psychological or mental health issue, and 1 in 5 were taking medications for mental health issues.’

Prison entrants in Australia also reported a history of engaging in various risky health behaviours at greater rates than the general community, such as smoking tobacco, using illicit drugs, and drinking alcohol at high levels.

‘Four in five prison entrants were smokers, and three in four said they smoked daily, while more than half reported drinking alcohol at risky levels,’ Mr Beard said.

‘Two-thirds of prison entrants said they’d used illicit drugs in the previous 12 months, and over half had injected drugs at some time in their life.’

The physical health of prisoners was also highlighted as a major concern—over a quarter of prison entrants had a chronic health condition such as asthma, arthritis, cardiovascular disease or diabetes, and a further 35% had tested positive to hepatitis C.

Indigenous prison entrants reported higher rates of risky health behaviours (such as smoking and alcohol consumption) than their non-Indigenous counterparts. However they reported lower levels of mental health related issues and some chronic conditions.

There were almost 29,000 prisoners in custody in Australia at 30 June 2010.

 

http://www.aihw.gov.au/media-release-detail/?id=10737420106

When flash mobs stop being fun

Star InactiveStar InactiveStar InactiveStar InactiveStar Inactive

Social data as a category surely includes information about new social phenomena?  Not quite a 'press cutting', because it's published by a university, this piece is simply valuable and interesting social information, very much linked to new social media.

http://www.phoenix.edu/colleges_divisions/criminal-justice/articles/2011/09/when-flash-mobs-stop-being-fun.html

Text Size