Warning: include(/home4/crimetal/public_html/J1xBackup/modules/mod_poll/user.php) [function.include]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /home4/crimetal/public_html/index.php on line 8

Warning: include() [function.include]: Failed opening '/home4/crimetal/public_html/J1xBackup/modules/mod_poll/user.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/opt/php53/lib/php') in /home4/crimetal/public_html/index.php on line 8

Warning: session_start() [function.session-start]: Cannot send session cookie - headers already sent by (output started at /home4/crimetal/public_html/index.php:8) in /home4/crimetal/public_html/libraries/joomla/session/session.php on line 678

Warning: session_start() [function.session-start]: Cannot send session cache limiter - headers already sent (output started at /home4/crimetal/public_html/index.php:8) in /home4/crimetal/public_html/libraries/joomla/session/session.php on line 678


An educational resource at the heart of criminological teaching, debate, and research


Register, Log In and click on 'Add new comment', at the end of the review, to comment on either the review or the book. 


Criminology goes to the Movies: Review by Steve Hall

User Rating: 5 / 5

Star activeStar activeStar activeStar activeStar active

Rafter, N. & Brown, M. (2011) Criminology Goes to the Movies: Crime, Theory and Popular Culture. New York: New York University Press. 227 pp.

In this book Rafter and Brown rise to the challenge of making criminological theory accessible, interesting and relevant by taking it to the movies. For a long time now, cinema has been residing at the heart popular culture, representing the world and exerting a heavy influence on the construction of meaning. This immediately strikes the reader as a bright idea for enhancing the often difficult task of teaching criminological theory, but, via the medium of cinema, it also complements cultural criminologyвАЩs traditional mode of thinking by bringing popular culture into criminology and setting it up as a field of study.  What makes the book interesting is, firstly, the crossover between the traditional practice of bringing the movies into criminology and the more original attempt to take criminological theory to the movies, and, secondly, the emphasis it places on the fact that вАШout thereвАЩ in popular culture itself is an ongoing form of informal criminological theorizing expedited by the relationship between various movies and their audiences. 

All this is well served by the way the book is organized. A crisp and clear introduction is followed by ten chapters in which selected criminological theories are applied to well-known movies. The order is roughly chronological, following the traditional linear means of arranging the 20th century theoretical canon. Each chapter consists of a brief description of the theoryвАЩs main tenets followed its application to a movie to produce a basic analysis, followed by brief discussions of other movies and concluding remarks. The bookвАЩs conclusion is very short, bowing out with a reminder of the authorsвАЩ principal claim; when people go to the movies they are actually engaging in an informal mode of theoretical criminology by using the representations supplied as intellectual tools. So, there is no reason why this type of informal theorizing cannot be invited into the formal domain as both an aid to and an object of study. Doing things this way also helps to build bridges between criminology, cultural studies and media studies. However, this project is already under way in the form of cultural criminology, so the authorsвАЩ claim that their work вАШexpands criminologyвАЩs boundariesвАЩ is perhaps a little too ambitious, but it certainly presents us with a novel way of approaching the subject. 

However, does this rather good idea actually work? The writing is clear and accessible, and the bright and breezy style, even if it does tend to gloss over what is often regarded as unavoidable depth and difficulty, will certainly appeal to both FE and first-year HE students, and possibly second-year students approaching either criminological theory or cultural criminology for the first time. Although many of the movies are quite old, and therefore not representative of popular culture today, the themes they address are timeless. I have no doubt that the approach laid out in the book will help students to get a firmer hold on introductory criminological theory and cultural criminology. There is no doubt that the book is an excellent study aid, suitable for a number of standard criminology modules.

On the other hand, because the book does its job as a study aid so well, compromises had to be made in the actual analyses themselves, which means that it does on some levels misfire as an intellectual exercise in its own right. Criminological theory tends to be linear and compartmentalized in its arrangement. The book follows this type of organization, and, because no attempt at integration or crossover is made, it doesnвАЩt so much вАШtake criminology to the moviesвАЩ as take various singular perspectives to various individual movies. This gives one the impression of standing outside a cinema as a procession of elderly and rather uncompromising criminological theorists, who have never spoken to each other, come out one by one to say briefly what they thought about the movies they have just watched. Most of the theories and theorists that feature in the book are rather dated; there is no discussion of recent advances, both innovative and integrative, made in criminological theory.

These very brief, demarcated analyses also suffer from being squeezed into small spaces, and at times seem clich√©d and mismatched. For instance, the choice of biological determinism in the analysis of James WhalesвАЩs camp rendition of Mary ShelleyвАЩs Frankenstein feels uncomfortable. The original Creature represented the resentful and volatile human victims of industrial capitalismвАЩs failed Promethean project вАУ вАЬI was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiendвАЭ вАУ and the story was an allegory based in the Romantic tradition that Shelley shared with the likes of William Blake. The Creature was aware of its monstrous form and misdeeds and sought equality, love and redemption. Rafter and Brown do acknowledge that the вАШcriminal brainвАЩ device in the movie was not part of the original story, but they seem to run shy of a deeper political analysis of why Whale and his screenwriters reduced ShelleyвАЩs complex and politically charged message to a simple вАШscientific mistakeвАЩ, thus shutting out politics and ushering in bio-criminology as a wholly inappropriate analytical tool.

The omission of the possibility that the moviemakers might have distorted the story for ideological motives reveals early in the book an underlying liberal-pluralist narrative, but todayвАЩs numerous radical analysts of cinema вАУ for instance Fredric Jameson or Slavoj ≈љi≈Њek вАУ are now placing libidinal drive, ideology and subjectivity rather than choice and agency at the centre of cultural studies. Rafter and Brown argue that criminological theories could be useful in the study of culture and media. However, it would be rather difficult to imagine such sophisticated thinkers salivating at the prospect of using creaky old criminological theories provided by the likes of Sutherland or Sampson and Laub, but far easier to imagine the reverse, i.e. criminological theory renewing itself as it draws upon these new wells of ideas and modifies them for its own purposes.

Other chapters are to some extent more convincing. It is certainly possible to imagine that Psycho can help us to explore multiple emotional current and countercurrents, and that Strain Theory and Institutional Anomie Theory can be brought alive by movies such as Traffic and Falling Down. However, the book again treads on shaky ground as the authors claim that Mystic River and Goodfellas lend themselves to subcultural theories; the violent leading characters could be possibly more convincingly depicted as unrefined versions of mainstream neoliberal culture. The chapters on labeling theory, conflict theory and Marxism are fairly straightforward and a little more convincing, but, again, ideology, hegemony, libido, subjectivity and the possibility of cultural incorporation вАУ all now back with a vengeance in current modes of radical thought вАУ are not discussed.

Rafter and Brown are unerringly correct that critical criminology is once more becoming relevant again as global capitalism dominates our lives, but the book would have been stronger had they identified and discussed some of the developments in radical thought upon which a renewed critical criminology could draw, and used todayвАЩs rapidly revitalizing critical criminology in an analysis of selected movies, perhaps in a final chapter to bring the whole thing up to date.

The chapter on feminist criminology states quite clearly that feminism has no grand theories to explain crime and instead highlights a вАШmultiplicity of gendered experiencesвАЩ, yet the movie вАУ Thelma and Louise вАУ and the analysis chosen are firmly grounded in an (anti-)patriarchal narrative that is as grand as it gets, replete with timeless stereotypes; most men are sexist beasts, domesticity is a cage, gender is an individual-cultural accomplishment, the вАШpatriarchyвАЩ is a combined force concentrated in the state and so on. No challenges to this well-worn narrative are discussed. In the current epoch of neoliberal dominance, deficit reduction and austerity, powerful conservative women are influential voices in the assaults on working people, some of whom, cast out with their children into neoliberalismвАЩs jobless and homeless margins, would give their right arms to be back in the вАШcageвАЩ of paid work and domesticity. A similar problem appears in the chapter on City of God. Here there is no mention of neoliberal restructuring, global drug markets and the problems of the permanently disrupted post-political, post-moral vortices that have appeared in Latin America. The authors choose to explain criminality by means of life-course theory, as if informal controls operate in a politico-economic vacuum. In todayвАЩs rather dismal yet volatile political and socioeconomic contexts, the narratives employed in these two chapters seem rather dated.

Overall, this book is an excellent teaching aid, but the lack of contemporary theoretical integration and synthesis, and the absence of new perspectives emerging from current movements in social theory, philosophy and cultural studies and now being incorporated by todayвАЩs criminological theorists, suggests that the authorsвАЩ ambition of providing either specialists in the field of popular culture or advanced students with theoretical perspectives for analyzing crime movies might be a little premature. The authors have chosen theories from an era when criminology had not even begun to break out of its subordinate position as an importer discipline. Consequently, at the moment, any attempt to return ideas to their place of origin will be rather like selling used coals to Newcastle. The book does its job and introduces students to some very basic applications of selected criminological theories, but it fails to warn them that this is just a scratch on the surface and there is much, much more.


Steve Hall is Professor of Criminology at the Social Futures Institute, Teesside University, UK

Rethinking Social Exclusion. Review of Winlow & Hall.

User Rating: 5 / 5

Star activeStar activeStar activeStar activeStar active

Rethinking Social Exclusion: The End of the Social. By Simon Winlow & Steve Hall. 2013. Sage. P/b £25.99, H/b £79.

The objective of this book by Simon Winlow and Steve Hall is to offer a fundamental and critically informed assessment of one of the most prominent themes in the social sciences, namely social exclusion. The term social exclusion has over time become a catchall shorthand cited by many but critically engaged with by few. It has become a ubiquitous term much bandied about with scant regard for its true epistemological meaning and seems to be de rigueur in utterances from academics, researchers, politicians, advocacy groups, campaigners and columnists all of whom appear to lament its extent, have varying understandings of what it is, and diverse opinions on how it should be remedied. It crops up with regularity in official press statements on social policies, and itвАЩs also an old reliable - explaining why disadvantaged estates need regeneration, why we must address anti-social behaviour, initiate youth diversion programmes, impose welfare to work schemes and social welfare reforms.

Read more: Rethinking Social Exclusion. Review of Winlow & Hall.

Bowling for Global Police: Review of Ben Bowling on global policing

User Rating: 5 / 5

Star activeStar activeStar activeStar activeStar active

Ben Bowling, Policing the Caribbean: Transnational Security Cooperation in Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010. 376pp. ISBN: 978-0-19-957769-9.

Leanne Weber and Ben Bowling (editors), Stop and Search: Police Power in Global Context. London and New York: Routledge, 2012. 140pp. ISBN: 978-0-415-63100-6.

Ben Bowling and James Sheptycki, Global Policing. London: Sage, 2012. 192pp. ISBN: 978-1-84920-082-0.


In 2013 those of us social science scholars interested in the systematic study of international policing have come a long way since the days of some two decades ago when the one published work useful in this area of research was political scientist Ethan NadelmannвАЩs book Cops Across Borders (Penn State University Press, 1993). And even though one could still write, by the turn towards the current century, that police activities of an international nature, whether cross-border or more or less global in kind, were a relatively neglected domain of research, by now it would be completely ridiculous and outright lacking in even the slightest form of intelligence to argue that not a lot of empirical and conceptual work on the practices of international policing, especially in connection with information-sharing, would have been undertaken. The exact opposite is now true as a variety of relevant studies have appeared, revealing important historical and contemporary dimensions in multiple contexts, that are so numerous that they cannot be cited in the context of this review without doing injustice to those that would not be mentioned.

Read more: Bowling for Global Police: Review of Ben Bowling on global policing

The Gang and Beyond: Review of Simon Hallsworth's book on gangs

User Rating: 4 / 5

Star activeStar activeStar activeStar activeStar inactive

Hallsworth, S. The Gang and Beyond: Interpreting Violent Street Worlds. Palgrave Macmillan: Basingstoke. 2013. ¬£25.99. ISBN 978-1-137358080


The growing field of cultural criminology, a love-child of critical criminology and cultural studies, is beginning to bloom. Authors such as Jeff Ferrell, Keith Hayward, Wayne Morrison, Mike Presdee and, the now late, Jock Young (among others) have been ploughing and promising what seems fertile new ground. Cultural studies in the British tradition always sought something new, either my experimenting with new methodologies, turning to philosophy and anthropology for new theoretical avenues: criminology has always been central to that project (e.g. Stuart Hall, Paul Willis, etc.). The Birmingham School has perished, but this turn toward culture is renewed, growing since the mid-1990s and it is now being explicitly and programmatically pursued in several criminology institutions and journals. This book of Simon Hallsworth marks a significant contribution in this respect.

Read more: The Gang and Beyond: Review of Simon Hallsworth's book on gangs

With Liberty and Justice for Some: How the Law is Used to Destroy Equality and Protect the Powerful

User Rating: 5 / 5

Star activeStar activeStar activeStar activeStar active

Glenn Greenwald (2011) With Liberty and Justice for Some: How the Law is Used to Destroy Equality and Protect the Powerful. New York, NY: Metropolitan Books, Henry Holt and Company, 304 pp. (h/b).

The U.S. is in the midst of one of the most significant crime waves in history, one in which serious and repeat offenders run afoul of the law with little fear of being caught or punished. While police have failed to investigate these crimes, politicians, particularly those with an affinity for law-and-order policies, have turned a blind eye, preferring to enact laws that prevent offenders from being held to account. What is more, the majority of American citizens appear unconcerned about the situation, mostly unaware of their own victimization. All of this begs the question: has the U.S. become a вАЬlawlessвАЭ society?

This latest book by U.S. political commentator and former federal litigator, Glenn Greenwald, provides much needed insight into AmericaвАЩs crime problem. However, this is not a book about street thugs, gun crimes, violent dogs or the use of CCTV in the вАШwarвАЩ on crime вАУ issues that dominate media headlines, political agendas and criminological research вАУ but about the culture of immunity enjoyed by AmericaвАЩs political and economic elite.

Read more: With Liberty and Justice for Some: How the Law is Used to Destroy Equality and Protect the Powerful

Text Size

New Directions in Criminological Theory

This edited collection by Steve Hall [Teesside U.] and Simon Winlow [York U., England] brings together established global scholars and new thinkers to outline fresh concepts and theoretical perspectives for criminological research and analysis in the 21stcentury. Criminologists from the UK, USA, Canada and Australia evaluate the current condition of criminological theory and present students and researchers with new and revised ideas from the realms of politics, culture and subjectivity to unpack crime and violence in the precarious age of global neoliberalism.

These ideas range from the micro-realm of the вАШpersonality disorderвАЩ to the macro-realm of global вАШpower-crimeвАЩ. Rejecting or modifying the orthodox notion that crime and harm are largely the products of criminalisation and control systems, these scholars bring causes and conditions back into play in an eclectic yet thematic way that should inspire students and researchers to once again investigate the reasons why some individuals and groups elect to harm others rather than seek sociability. This collection will inspire new criminologists to both look outside their discipline for new ideas to import, and to create new ideas within their discipline to reinvigorate it and further strengthen its ability to explain the crimes and harms that we see around us today.

This book will be of particular interest to academics and both undergraduate and postgraduate students in the field of criminology, especially to those looking for theoretical concepts and frameworks for dissertations, theses and research reports. For full details, go to: 


Introduction: The Need for вАШNew DirectionsвАЩ in Criminological Theory, Steve Hall and Simon Winlow Part 1: Epistemological and Political Reflections 1. Criminological Knowledge: Doing Critique; Doing Politics, Pat Carlen 2. Political Economy and Criminology: The Return of the Repressed, Robert Reiner 3. Critical Criminology, Critical Theory and Social Harm, Majid Yar 4. The Current Condition of Criminological Theory in North America, Walter DeKeseredy Part 2: Criminological Theory, Culture and the Subject 5. The Biological and the Social in Criminological Theory, Tim Owen 6.From Social Order to the Personal Subject: A Major Reversal, Michel Wieviorka 7. The Discourse on вАШRaceвАЩ in Criminological Theory, Colin Webster 8. Using Cultural Geography to Think Differently about Space and Crime, Keith Hayward 9.Consumer Culture and the Meaning of the Urban Riots in England, Steve Hall 10. Censure, culture and political economy: beyond the death of deviance debate, Colin Sumner Part 3: Criminological Theory and Violence 11. Psychosocial Perspectives: Men, Madness and Violence, D.W. Jones 12. All that is Sacred is Profaned: Towards a Theory of Subjective Violence, Simon Winlow 13. Late Capitalism, Vulnerable Populations and Violent Predatory Crime, David Wilson Part 4: Crime and Criminological Theory in the Global Age 14. Outline of a Criminology of Drift, Jeff Ferrell Ch. 15. It Was Never About the Money: Market Society, Organized Crime and UK Criminology,Dick Hobbs 16. After the Crisis: New Directions in Theorising Corporate and White-Collar Crime, Kate Burdis and Steve Tombs 17. Crimes against Reality: Parapolitics, Simulation, Power Crime, Eric Wilson Ch. 18. Global Terrorism, Risk and the State, Sandra Walklate and Gabe Mythen